top of page

When Managers Bring Every Problem Upward, Ask What They Have Already Considered

3 hours ago
3 min read
Team members discussing a project together in an office

Photo: Ivan S / Pexels. Illustrative stock image.


When managers repeatedly bring routine decisions to the owner, ask them to explain the options they considered and the recommendation they would make. This creates an opportunity to develop judgment. It should never become a rule that people must solve a serious problem before they are allowed to raise it.


For an owner leading a business with 10–100 employees, the challenge is familiar: answering the question yourself feels faster. But if every similar question comes back tomorrow, the immediate answer has not helped the manager learn how to decide.


Distinguish uncertainty from lack of authority


Start by asking why the manager brought the issue upward. They may lack information, face competing priorities, or need approval outside their authority. They may also be following a pattern created by an owner who regularly reverses their decisions.


These situations need different responses. More coaching will not fix missing access to a customer agreement. A demand for initiative will not fix an undefined spending limit. Ask what prevented a decision before assuming the manager lacks confidence.


Then identify which part the manager can own. They may be able to gather facts and recommend an option even when the final approval remains with the owner.


Request a brief that fits the decision


For a routine operational issue, ask the manager to bring a short explanation: what happened, what decision is needed, which options are realistic, what they recommend, and when the answer is required.


This is a thinking aid, not a paperwork requirement. A verbal explanation may be enough for a small decision. A written note is more useful when several departments, significant costs, or a lasting change are involved.


In a hypothetical service business, a supervisor may ask whether to move a customer deadline. Their brief should explain the capacity constraint, the customer impact, and the alternatives considered. The owner can then discuss the tradeoff rather than reconstruct the entire situation.


Coach the reasoning before supplying the answer


Ask a few questions that reveal how the manager evaluated the choice. What fact could change the recommendation? Who else is affected? Which consequence is reversible? What would need to be monitored after the decision?


Do not turn the conversation into a test with an answer the manager must guess. If you know a material fact they do not know, share it. If you reject their recommendation, explain the reasoning so they can use it next time.


There will still be moments when speed matters and you need to decide directly. Return afterward to explain the decision. Otherwise, the manager sees the outcome without learning the judgment that produced it.


Keep a clear route for immediate escalation


“Bring solutions, not problems” can become an unhelpful slogan. Employees should be able to raise urgent safety concerns, suspected misconduct, sensitive employee matters, or other serious risks promptly, even when they do not have a proposed remedy.


Agree on escalation routes for those situations separately. The coaching brief is intended for ordinary management decisions; it is not a gate that blocks reporting or access to support.


Also tell managers when they have waited too long. A polished recommendation that arrives after a preventable deadline failure is less useful than an early warning that gives the business time to respond.


Review decisions after the result is visible


Choose a small number of completed decisions for review. Compare what the manager expected with what happened. Identify which assumptions held, which information was missing, and what they would do differently.


Avoid judging the reasoning only by whether the result was favorable. A sound decision can meet an unexpected obstacle. A weak decision can get lucky. Discuss the process and the outcome separately.


Over time, look for fewer repeated questions about the same issue, clearer recommendations, and earlier warnings about changing conditions. These are more useful coaching observations than simply counting how often a manager asks for help.


What if the manager is new?


Provide examples and a smaller decision boundary first. Practice with a low-risk scenario before expecting independent judgment in a complex situation. Make support available while gradually expanding responsibility.


Turn one recurring question into practice


Select one routine decision that keeps returning to the owner. Define the information required, the manager's authority, and the point at which escalation is necessary. Use the next occurrence as a coaching opportunity.


Human Capital Consultants International (HCCI), led by Leyda Lazo, supports executive coaching and manager development within HRO FullScope. Connect with HCCI to make the development of management judgment part of your operating rhythm.


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page