Gross Margin Is Falling: Check the Accounting Before Changing Prices
By Leyda Lazo, SHRM-SCP | Human Capital Consultants International (HCCI)
HCCI Insights · November 15, 2026 · Cash Flow & Financial Strategy
Before responding to a falling gross margin, check whether revenue and direct costs are classified consistently and recorded in the appropriate periods. Then separate an accounting problem from a genuine change in the economics of the business.
What the numbers need to tell you
Gross margin compares revenue with the costs classified as cost of goods sold or cost of services under your reporting approach. A change in classification can alter the reported margin without changing total profit. Timing, product mix, discounts, supplier costs, and delivery inefficiencies can also matter.
Three practical steps
Compare the chart of accounts and reporting definitions with prior periods. Identify costs moved between direct costs and operating expenses, and ask the accountant to explain the treatment.
Review significant transactions near period-end. Check whether associated revenue and costs were recorded consistently with the accounting basis rather than simply when someone entered the invoice.
Analyze margin by a useful product, service, or customer group. Explain price, volume, mix, and cost changes separately before selecting a commercial response.
A closer look at the decision
Compare margin using a consistent definition of sales and direct costs. Freight, rebates, returns, and subcontractor charges may be recorded in different accounts or periods, which can make a trend appear better or worse than the underlying activity. Once the records are reliable, separate supplier-price changes, sales-price changes, and product mix. A price increase may be appropriate, but it should follow an understanding of the economics. Otherwise, the company can raise prices to solve a coding problem while missing a real purchasing issue elsewhere.
A hypothetical example
Imagine revenue of $100,000 and direct costs of $60,000, producing $40,000 of gross profit and a 40% gross margin. Moving $5,000 from operating expenses into direct costs lowers the reported gross margin to 35%, even though total operating expense and profit have not changed.
Use a consistent cost definition
Before comparing alternatives, agree what is included in revenue, direct costs, and any shared-cost allocation. Use the same period and level of completeness for each comparison. A result based on full costs should not be compared casually with one that excludes important items. Where estimates are necessary, label them and explain the method so management can judge how much confidence to place in the result.
Separate the accounting description from the business response. An allocated cost may be useful for one analysis without representing cash that would disappear if activity stopped. Likewise, a lower unit cost can come with a larger cash commitment. Ask which costs would actually change under the proposed decision and over what time frame. That turns a margin or cost report into a more useful basis for pricing, purchasing, and investment discussions.
A question owners ask
Is one month enough to judge the result?
Sometimes it reveals an urgent issue, but it may not represent the normal economics. Review the relevant period, unusual transactions, incomplete costs, and seasonal patterns before drawing a broad conclusion. Use the most recent evidence without assuming that every short-term movement will continue. If the analysis remains sensitive to missing information, identify what must be confirmed before taking a major action.
The point to keep in view
Do not compare margin percentages across reports that use different definitions of direct cost.
Your next step
Reconcile the inputs, state the cost definition, and test the conclusion against the decision being considered. Document which costs and cash flows would actually change. Use that evidence to discuss a specific pricing, purchasing, or operating adjustment rather than reacting to an unexplained margin percentage.
Keep this review proportionate to the amount and the decision involved. Start with the most significant uncertainty, resolve it with the appropriate records and adviser, and document the conclusion. A focused review that produces an explained number and a clear next action is more useful than collecting additional reports without resolving the original question.
Have a question about organizing your company’s accounting function? Contact HCCI to discuss the support you need and the scope of an appropriate engagement.



Comments